This got me thinking about the differences between the birds we caught at Porthgwarra in 2011 and the birds we now catch at Lizard (2012-15). The pattern of movements always struck me as being a bit different between the two sites, but is there really anything in it? In 2011 we ringed 190 birds at Porthgwarra (with 6 controls) and since then we've ringed 565 birds at Lizard (with 20 controls). The movements these sessions have generated re shown below:
|From Lizard||To Lizard||From Porthgwarra||To Porthgwarra|
|Isles of Scilly||3||2|
|Isle of Man||1|
Some of the differences are interesting, with numerous movements between Porthgwarra and Ireland (Counties Wexford, Sligo and Mayo), but none to/from Lizard. But our ringing at Lizard has shared many birds with Welsh sites, whereas we never traded a Porthgwarra bird with Wales. The obvious explanation for the Welsh movements is the increased ringing activity on the Welsh Islands in recent years, in particular on Skokholm. The table below shows the national ringing totals from the BTO's online ringing report and the big increase in effort in Wales is pretty obvious! But there's no real change in effort in Ireland (the figures here are for the Republic of Ireland), so the fact that none of our Lizard birds have been found there is unusual.
Whilst I was looking at all these recoveries, I thought I'd also look at the length of time between ringing and finding. It is generally thought that birds attracted to 'tapes' are non-breeding, prospecting birds in the first few years of life. This fits with our captures, with most birds being recaught in the next summer or sooner. Obviously there are some very quick movements between sites (we've had one day movement to/from both south Wales and France), but recaptures after more than two years are unusual. In fact, the longest time elapsed was the Burhou-ringed bird mentioned right at the start, recaught five years after ringing.
So whilst a quick look at the data doesn't really answer many questions, it certainly poses a few more questions and we'll just have to keep ringing birds to find the answers!
In other news, we have also just received a sighting of one of our Cormorants in France: our first foreign movement! TBD was ringed on Mullion Island in May (see blog post here) and was seen yesterday on Banneg in the Molene archipelago.
|Thanks to Helen Maheo for the photo of TBD on Banneg|